“Dancing” raisins – a straightforward kitchen experiment shows how objects can draw energy from their surroundings and are available to life

Scientific discoveries don't at all times require a high-tech laboratory or an enormous budget. Many people have a first-class laboratory right at home – of their kitchen.

The kitchen offers quite a few opportunities to view and explore what physicists call soft matter and sophisticated fluids. Everyday phenomena like Cheerios buildup in milk or rings left behind when coffee drops evaporate have led to this Discoveries on the interface of physics and chemistry and other tasteful collaborations between Food scientist and physicist.

Two students, Sam Christianson and Carsen Grote, and I published a brand new study in Nature Communications in May 2024, which deals with one other kitchen statement. We've been studying how objects can float in carbonated liquids, a phenomenon whimsically called “dancing raisins.”

The study examined how objects like raisins can move rhythmically up and down in carbonated liquids for several minutes, even as much as an hour.

An accompanying one Twitter thread about our research went viral, garnering over half 1,000,000 views in only two days. Why has this particular experiment captured the imagination of so many individuals?

Bubbling physics

Mineral water and other carbonated drinks fizz with bubbles because they contain more gas than the liquid can hold – they’re “supersaturated” with gas. If you Open a bottle of champagne or a soft drink, the liquid pressure drops and CO₂ molecules begin to flee into the encompassing air.

Bubbles don’t normally form spontaneously in a liquid. A liquid is made up of molecules that wish to stick together, so the molecules on the liquid boundary are somewhat unhappy. That results in Surface tension, a force aimed toward reducing surface area. Because bubbles increase the surface area, surface tension and fluid pressure normally immediately displace any bubbles that form.

But rough spots on a container's surface, just like the engravings in some champagne glasses, can protect recent bubbles from the crushing effects of surface tension, giving them a likelihood to form and grow.

Bubbles also form within the microscopic, tubular fabric fibers which can be left behind once you wipe a glass with a towel. The bubbles grow continuously in these tubes Once large enough, they detach and float upwards, expelling gas from the container.

But as many Champagne enthusiasts who add fruit to their glasses know, surface etching and small fabric fibers aren't the one places where bubbles can form. Add a small item like a raisin or a peanut to a sparkling drink also enables bubble growth. These submerged objects function tantalizing recent surfaces on which opportunistic molecules like CO₂ can accumulate and form bubbles.

And once enough bubbles have grown on the item, an act of levitation may be performed. Together, the bubbles can lift the item to the surface of the liquid. Once the bubbles reach the surface, they burst and cause the item to fall back down. Then the method begins again, in a periodic vertical dance movement.

Dancing raisins

Raisins are particularly good dancers. It only takes a couple of seconds for enough bubbles to form on the wrinkled surface of a raisin before it begins to rise to the highest – bubble formation is tougher on smoother surfaces. If a raisin is dipped in just-opened mineral water, it may possibly dance a vigorous tango for 20 minutes after which a slower waltz for one more hour or so.

Anyone with a couple of kitchen staples can conduct their very own experiment with dancing raisins.

We found that rotation or rotation is crucial make large objects dance. Bubbles that cling to the underside of an object can keep it aloft even when the highest bubbles pop. But when the item begins to rotate even a little bit, the bubbles underneath rotate the body even faster, causing much more bubbles to burst on the surface. And the earlier these bubbles are removed, the earlier the item can return to its vertical dance.

Small objects like raisins don't spin as much as larger objects, but as an alternative spin and wiggle forwards and backwards quickly.

Modeling the bubbly flamenco

In the work, we developed a mathematical model to predict how often an object like a raisin would come to the surface. In one experiment, we placed a 3D printed ball that acted as a model of a raisin in a glass of just-opened mineral water. The ball traveled up from the underside of the container over 750 times in an hour.

The model installed the speed of bubble growth in addition to the form, size and surface roughness of the item. This also took into consideration how quickly the liquid loses carbon dioxide resulting from the container geometry and specifically the flow generated by the bubbling activity.

Small bubble-covered objects in carbonated water move up to the surface and back down.
Bubble-covered raisins “dance” to the surface and fall as soon as their lifting devices are ruptured.
Saverio spagnolia

Using the mathematical model, we were in a position to determine which forces had the best influence on the item's dance. For example, the fluid resistance on the item turned out to be relatively unimportant, however the ratio of the item's surface area to its volume was crucial.

Looking forward, the model also provides a method to determine some difficult-to-measure quantities using simpler measurable quantities. For example, just by observing the dance frequency of an object, we will learn rather a lot about its surface at a microscopic level without having to directly see these details.

Different dances in numerous theaters

However, these results will not be only interesting for lovers of carbonated drinks. There are also supersaturated liquids in nature – for instance magma.

As magma in a volcano rises closer to the Earth's surface, the pressure drops rapidly and dissolved gases from contained in the volcano rush toward the exit, identical to the CO₂ in carbonated water. These escaping gases can form into large high-pressure bubbles and emerge with such force that a a volcanic eruption occurs.

The particles in magma may not dance in the identical way as raisins in soda water, but tiny objects within the magma can influence the progression of those explosive events.

In recent many years there has also been an outbreak of a special kind: hundreds of scientific studies have been dedicated to lively matter in liquids. These studies have a look at things like floating microorganisms and that The within our fluid-filled cells.

Most of those lively systems exist not in water, but in additional complicated biological fluids that contain the energy needed to supply activity. Microorganisms absorb nutrients from the fluid around them with a purpose to proceed swimming. Molecular motors move cargo along a highway inside our cells by drawing energy from the environment in the shape of ATP from the encompassing area.

Studying these systems can assist scientists learn more about how the cells and bacteria within the human body function and the way life on this planet evolved to its current state.

Meanwhile, a liquid itself can behave strangely resulting from the difference in molecular composition and the bodies moving inside it. Many recent studies for instance, have checked out the behavior of microorganisms in liquids equivalent to mucus, which behaves each like a viscous liquid and an elastic gel. Scientists still have rather a lot to study these highly complex systems.

While raisins in soda water seem quite easy in comparison with microorganisms floating through biological fluids, they supply an accessible method to study generic traits in these more difficult environments. In each cases, bodies extract energy from their complex fluid environments and concurrently influence them, resulting in fascinating behaviors.

New insights into the physical world, from geophysics to biology, will proceed to emerge from table-scale experiments—and maybe right within the kitchen.

image credit : theconversation.com