In the 18 months after Francine Milano was diagnosed with a relapse of the ovarian cancer she thought she had beaten 20 years ago, she traveled twice from her home in Pennsylvania to Vermont. She traveled to not ski, hike or leaf peek, but to arrange for her death.
“I really wanted to have control over how I left this world,” said the 61-year-old, who lives in Lancaster. “I decided this was an option for me.”
When Milano learned in early 2023 that her disease was incurable, dying with medical assistance was not an option. At that time, she would have needed to travel to Switzerland – or the District of Columbia or certainly one of the 10 countries where physician-assisted suicide was legal.
But Vermont lifted its residency requirement in May 2023, followed by Oregon two months later. (Montana effectively allows assisted suicide by a court decision from 2009but this ruling doesn’t contain any rules on residency. And although New York and California recently considered Neither provision was passed, although there was no laws that will allow non-residents to receive euthanasia.)
Despite the limited options and challenges – reminiscent of finding doctors in a brand new state, deciding where to die and traveling when too sick to enter the following room, let alone get in a automotive – dozens have made the trek to the 2 states which have opened their doors to terminally in poor health out-of-towners looking for assisted dying.
At least 26 people have traveled to Vermont to die, representing nearly 25% of the reported assisted dying within the state from May 2023 to June of this 12 months, in keeping with the Vermont Department of Health. In Oregon, 23 out-of-state residents died with medical assistance in 2023, just over 6% of the state total, in keeping with the Oregon Health Authority.
Oncologist Charles Blanke, whose Portland clinic makes a speciality of end-of-life care, believes Oregon's total might be an underestimate and expects the numbers to rise. Over the past 12 months, he has seen two to 4 out-of-state patients every week — a few quarter of his practice — and has fielded calls from all around the U.S., including New York, the Carolinas, Florida and “tons from Texas.” But simply because patients are willing to travel doesn't mean it's easy or that they'll get the consequence they need.
“The law is pretty strict about what needs to be done,” Blanke said.
Like other states that allow so-called physician-assisted dying or assisted suicide, patients in Oregon and Vermont should be examined by two physicians. Patients will need to have lower than six months to live, be mentally and cognitively healthy, and be physically in a position to take the medication to finish their life. Medical records and health records should be verified in-state. Failure to achieve this is taken into account practicing medicine out of state, which violates medical licensing requirements. For the identical reason, patients should be in-state for the initial examination, when the medication is requested, and when it’s taken.
State legislatures impose these restrictions as protective measures – to balance the rights of patients looking for assisted dying with the legislative imperative to not pass laws that harm anyone, said Peg Sandeen, CEO of the group. Dying with dignityHowever, like many other supporters of euthanasia, she said such regulations placed an unreasonable burden on individuals who were already suffering.
Diana Barnard, a palliative care physician in Vermont, said some patients can't even make it to their appointments. “They're sick or don't feel like traveling, so they have to reschedule their appointments,” she said. “People have to spend a lot of their energy coming here when they really deserve an option closer to home.”
Opponents of euthanasia include religious groups who say that killing a human being is immoral, and Doctors who argue that their role is to enable people to live more comfortably at the tip of their lives and never to finish life itself.
anthropologist Anita Hannigwho researched her 2022 book “The Day I Die: The Untold Story of Assisted Dying in America,” she said she doesn’t expect federal laws to deal with the problem any time soon. As the Supreme Court did with abortion in 2022, it ruled in 1997 that assisted suicide was a state rights matter.
During the 2023-24 legislative period 19 states (including Milan's home state of Pennsylvania) was considering assisted suicide laws, in keeping with the advocacy group Compassion and decisionsDelaware was the one state that pass ithowever the governor has not taken any motion yet.
Sandeen said many states initially enact restrictive laws — reminiscent of 21-day waiting periods and mental health evaluations — after which eventually repeal provisions that prove to be overly burdensome. That makes her optimistic that more states will follow the lead of Vermont and Oregon, she said.
Milano would have preferred to travel to neighboring New Jersey, where assisted suicide has been legal since 2019, but residency requirements made that unattainable. And although there are more providers in Oregon than within the largely rural state of Vermont, Milano selected the nine-hour drive to Burlington since it was less physically and financially demanding than traveling across the country.
Logistics were crucial because Milano knew she needed to return. She wasn't near death when she traveled to Vermont along with her husband and brother in May 2023. She figured the following time she was in Vermont, she would request the drug. Then she would must wait 15 days to receive it.
The waiting period is standard to make sure an individual has enough time to think in regards to the decision, as Barnard calls it, though she said most would have done so long before then. Some states have shortened the period or, like Oregon, created an exemption.
That wait may be hard on patients, along with being separated from their health care team, home and family. Blanke said he's seen as many as 25 relatives present on the death of an Oregon resident, but out-of-towners typically bring just one person. And while finding a spot to die generally is a problem for Oregonians living in nursing homes or hospitals where assisted dying is prohibited, it's especially difficult for non-residents.
When Oregon lifted the residency requirement, Blanke posted an ad on Craigslist and used the outcomes to create an inventory of short-term shelters, including Airbnbs, that permit patients die. Nonprofits in states with assisted dying laws also maintain such lists, Sandeen says.
Milano isn’t yet at the purpose where she needs to seek out a spot to take the drugs and end her life. Because she had a comparatively healthy 12 months after her first trip to Vermont, she let her six-month approval period pass.
In June, nonetheless, she headed back to open one other six-month window. This time, she was traveling with a friend who has a trailer. They drove six hours to cross the state line. Stop at a playground and a souvenir shop before sitting in a parking zone where Milano had a Zoom appointment along with her doctors as a substitute of driving one other three hours to Burlington to satisfy them in person.
“I don't know if they do GPS tracking or things like that with IP addresses, but I would have been afraid of not being honest,” she said.
But that's not all that scares her. She fears she'll be too sick to return to Vermont when she's able to die. And even when she makes it there, she wonders if she'll have the courage to take the medication. About a 3rd of people who find themselves approved for assisted dying don't undergo with it, Blanke says. For them, knowing they’ve the medication – the control – to finish their lives after they want is commonly enough.
Milano said she is grateful to have this chance now and to still be healthy enough to travel and revel in life. “I just wish more people had this opportunity,” she said.
___
©2024 KFF Health News. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
image credit : www.mercurynews.com