Robert F. Kennedy Jr., President Donald Trump's nominee for director of the Department of Health and Human Services, has announced a daring plan. He wants “Make America Healthy Again.”
Kennedy's strategy has received much attention for its curiosities, corresponding to its opposition to Vaccination requirements and support for raw milk. But it incorporates some concepts which might be so many Public health experts For example, we predict it is sensible to call for a greater deal with the prevention of chronic diseases and for greater restrictions on promoting for pharmaceuticals aimed toward consumers.
But he also calls for a ban on junk food Supplemental Nutrition Support Program. Banning junk food from SNAP has caused division Public health experts for years.
As public health Researcherwe’ve got dedicated our careers to reducing chronic disease. We agree with Kennedy that healthy eating and nutrition are vital ways to enhance the nation's health. We also know from our own research that safety net programs, including SNAP advantages—sometimes still called food stamps—delay Hunger and food insecurity for hundreds of thousands of Americans.
And we’re sure tighten the restrictions even further that already limit access to SNAP advantages do little to make Americans healthier.
What is SNAP?
Over 42.1 million Americans, about 13% of all families, Receive SNAP advantages. More than one in 4 households participating in this system have someone earning not less than some income.
More than 4 out of 5 families get it SNAP advantages include children, people over age 65, or individuals with a disability. These advantages are distributed monthly via an electronic profit transfer card, which looks and functions like a credit or debit card and may be utilized in supermarkets and other approved retailers. The federal government has greater than $110 billion spent invited to this program yearly in recent times.
Benefits help put food on the table, but normally don't cover every thing A family has to eat. The The average monthly profit is $195 per person.
Americans who earn lower than 130% of the poverty line are eligible for SNAP. A family of three in fiscal 12 months 2025 I can't make greater than $2,152 a month in net income or have assets of greater than $4,500 if there’s an individual over 60 living in a household, and $3,000 if there will not be.
Adults without children or disabilities cannot receive these advantages for greater than three months every three years unless they meet the necessities Program work requirements by being employed or participating in a training program for not less than 20 hours per week. Strikers and aliens living within the United States without authorization should not eligible. People with previous convictions for drug offenses are affected Federal ban on SNAP for all timesbut states can waive this rule. This program is federally funded but administered by the states which have done so some flexibility in determining eligibility.
People enrolled in SNAP are already facing some Limitations on what they should purchase with their benefits. You cannot use SNAP to buy prepared or restaurant meals, alcohol, tobacco, or things like diapers, vitamins, and bathroom paper.
Why limit SNAP?
Because SNAP is run by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Kennedy would have little or no authority to vary SNAP rules if the Senate approved his nomination controversial politician upcoming Confirmation hearing is Jan. 29, 2025.
Nevertheless, we fear that his support for brand new restrictions could help influence the authorities who can be accountable for that? for somebody like that Policy change.
Suggestions to ban certain foods from SNAP have been made several times State legislature And Members of Congress through the years.
These bills are generally designed to effect exclusion supposedly luxury itemscorresponding to steaks and seafood, or with the aim of banning purchases on one other supermarket shelf: Candy, soda and other junk foods.
States cannot make any such change without USDA approval. And that's what the USDA has done to date rejected calls that it allows such measures. Even without the agency's support, Congress could make changes to those guidelines within the Farm Billwhich could force the USDA in the longer term to permit these restrictions in states that require them.
The Trump administration, including Kennedy, has expressed interest such restrictions.
Why SNAP restrictions won't make America healthier
While improving the American weight loss program is a worthy goal, research we and other scientists have conducted clearly shows that imposing latest restrictions on SNAP will do little to make us a healthier nation.
First, many studies have found that nearly all Americans could eat healthier.
In the United States, wealthy and poor alike eat unhealthy foods
Studies show that lower-income Americans often spend more of their grocery budget on unhealthy items than wealthier people Families in the center and at the highest of the income ladder are still buying plenty of junk food.
Not surprisingly, these purchases reflect what we eat: Americans of all income levels Having diets that aren't filling Federal Dietary Guidelines. Highlighting the poor eating habits of SNAP participants would and does distract from these facts Risk of further stigmatization a successful anti-hunger program.
Good nutrition is significant not low-cost or easyespecially with low incomes. The The poorest communities have much more There are cheaper fast food chains and dollar stores than their wealthier neighbors and there’s more promoting for unhealthy products. Even when receiving SNAP advantages, many Americans still struggle to make ends meet, and studies show the negative impact this has the standard of their weight loss program.
Another reason why SNAP restrictions wouldn't make America healthier is that weight loss program is just one in all many aspects chronic diseases. Your level of physical activity, exposure to pollution, stress and your genetics, amongst other things, influence your risk of developing heart disease, diabetes or other diseases chronic diseases.
Flexible, but doesn’t cover all needs
SNAP advantages are quite flexible and canopy almost anything people need to eat, even in the event that they have dietary restrictions as a consequence of their culture or health status. The program helps Americans afford most of their basic needs, even though it fails to achieve this Most people pay for all groceries Anyone who relies on this system must purchase it over the course of a month.
SNAP's primary mission is to forestall the worst effects of hunger and food insecurity for the greater than 41 million individuals who depend on it.
There are other ways for the federal government to assist Americans develop into healthier than by imposing stigmatizing restrictions on SNAP. For example, matching programs may be created for SNAP dollars spent on fruit and veggies. This would incentivize retailers to supply more products and make it easier for shoppers to purchase them SNAP advantages when purchasing healthier foods. The The USDA has began providing support This kind of effort exists in several states.
image credit : theconversation.com