Will business thrive under a second Donald Trump presidency? As far as I can tell, many business leaders are pinning their hopes on the idea that he won't actually follow through on his campaign guarantees on tariffs and mass deportations — that they will likely be like his border wall, which is a lot of the part he never built , but claimed he did.
But I consider this optimism is misplaced. Trump's obsession with tariffs and immigration goes back a great distance, and he probably won't respond well if people ridicule him for failing to implement his typical policy ideas.
If he doesn't moderate his policies, the damage will likely be significant – greater than even pessimists consider. Hostility toward immigrants not only creates labor shortages for lots of the strenuous manual jobs that U.S.-born Americans are reluctant to perform. It can even undermine American technological leadership.
As chances are you’ll know, Trump has declared his intention to declare a national emergency and use the military to assist round up large numbers of immigrants living within the United States illegally by first bringing them into what Stephen Miller, certainly one of his top immigration advisers, said: has called “huge reception facilities.”
Such actions could be a humanitarian and civil rights nightmare. But these considerations are unlikely to discourage Trump. If anything, he might welcome a riot because it will make him look strong and determined.
Ugly – or very ugly
The economic impact may very well be one other matter. Mass deportations would create shortages and drive up prices in industries that employ large numbers of non-permanent immigrants (plus legal residents who could also be caught within the dragnet), including agriculture, meat processing, and construction.
I truthfully don't understand how this is able to all play out, and I doubt anyone does. Would or not it’s ugly? Or would it not be very ugly?
Beyond these short-term effects, nevertheless, there’s likely a consequence of Trumpism that has not received much attention: the threat it is going to pose to American technological leadership.
Our technology sector is the wonder of the world. Around 1995, the world's major wealthy economies all seemed to be at roughly the identical level of technology and with similar levels of productivity; If Europe had a lower real GDP per capita, certainly one of the most important reasons could be that Europeans work fewer hours because, unlike us, they take real vacations.
But as a recent report for the European Commission by Mario Draghi, a former president of the European Central Bank, shows, America has made renewed progress in recent a long time. What I find interesting about this recovery within the US is that it isn’t broad-based: Europeans do most things about in addition to we do. Instead, it's about America taking the lead in digital technology.
What drives this success story? Undoubtedly, it has several causes, not least the network externalities created by the Silicon Valley technology cluster, which has an incredibly high per capita income. But whenever you spend time in America's tech hubs, it becomes clear that immigrants – often highly educated immigrants from South Asia and East Asia – also play a key role within the story.
Well, you would possibly say that this shouldn't be an issue. MAGA's antipathy is directed at immigrants within the United States illegally taking blue-collar jobs, not tech wizards from India, right?
Incorrect.
Target specialists
The first Trump administration was clearly hostile to legal, well-educated immigrants and employees living here illegally. This has made it significantly harder for highly qualified foreigners who can primarily work here to acquire or extend a visa. And lots of these employees fear that these policies will return, only worse.
If you wish to get a way of what Trump's inner circle likely believes, it's price taking a take a look at a 2016 conversation between Miller and Steve Bannon, a longtime Trump ally who was released from prison in time to to campaign for Trump. Bannon declared that legal immigration was the true problem and denounced the “oligarchs” who recruit foreigners for IT jobs that he said should go to Americans. “Well, that was brilliantly put,” Miller replied.
Does it matter that a few of these oligarchs, most notably Elon Musk, were big Trump supporters? Probably lower than you’re thinking that. Historically, oligarchs who consider they’ve bought influence from an authoritarian leader find that they’re much more depending on his goodwill than on his money. I believe that Musk specifically will soon learn that he needs Trump greater than Trump needs him.
So I could be very surprised if the anti-immigrant turnaround resulted in well-educated employees being spared. Beyond specific policies, the openness of our society is one reason America is so successful at attracting the world's best and brightest. Perhaps greater than another nation, we have now been a spot where people from different cultures can feel welcome. This era may very well be coming to an end.
Over the following few years, the proposed raids and detention facilities would likely dominate the news, and rightly so. But in a decade, we may additionally realize that by cracking down on immigrants, we have now undermined the tech sector, certainly one of the things that really makes America great.
image credit : www.mercurynews.com